14. Regardless, the entire affair felt vaguely defensive. Congresswoman Wyatt (Toby's ex-wife) arrives to talk to Toby about the speech - in which there are passages that she and several other members of the House International Relations Committee take issue with. ", As a Black Panamanian woman, recording artist and curator DioMara tells Allure she avoided bright colors, including red, when she was growing up because she was told it didnt flatter her complexion and that it was connected to more promiscuous women. Sam Seaborn If somebody says something that offends you, tell them. Its Toby. Plus Charlie said he's fine with it. With that, I'm going to get a cupcake. But, even as cosmetic lines catering to women of color began to emerge, old stereotypes from the 18th and 19th centuries of red lips being solely reserved for prostitutes seemingly extended over for WOC in the 20th century who dared paint their lips rouge. He would be able to. : 's office to tell Billy's wife that he is dead. Then you're fine. You -to Charlie- I don't know what your thing is. Feminism and Futurity: Geographies of resistance, resilience and reworking, MacLeavy, Fanning, Larner. The idea of blending in or assimilating to fit the idea of a "good minority" is psychologically harmful, especially to a young person wanting to experiment with creating their own identity through makeup. Feminist scholars like Fionnghuala Sweeney and Kathy Davis argue that there is a freedom that can come from understanding and embracing gender norms of sexuality as a means of freeing yourself from the stereotypes of women in society. I think it enhances it. Sam Seaborn "There is nothing like the jolt you get from wearing the right energetic red. I think you do. Sam Seaborn I call it stiletto feminism. [11] The reclaiming of this word has helped to spur the transnational movement of the SlutWalk.[12]. It might be Amy Gardner saying this, but not sure on that. And that I'm all man. Ainsley Hayes : Many stereotypes on red lips continue to persist today. C.J. : I think you do. Ainsley tells Celia to let it go. These are all wonderful ideas that Im glad made it onto televised entertainment. [22] The series follows the lives of four women living within New York City, navigating their relationships and sex lives together while tackling themes such as safe sex, promiscuity, and femininity. Inevitably though, she breaks down, and offers a peek behind the curtain of how tough it must be for CJ to let people down, day-in and day-out; hell, she cant even provide reporters with the draft of the speech they so desperately want. As a result, they would often take on physical male characteristics and a persona that was far from what the average woman looked like. Well, for the moment at least, I'm gonna do what she's telling me to do. He stands firm to his beliefs, and does what he can to share those beliefs with a larger populationwhether you like them or not. Charlie Young : Hes a writer, and as one of my former bosses said once about the comedy business, The difference between a writer and a producer is that a writer is allowed to have his own opinion. Bartlet is the producer; Toby is the writer. Sentiments began to change once marketing made "paint and powder" cosmetics more easily accessible. Filming & Production The depictions of excessive and complex breakups, career-oriented women, owning of sexuality, and the blunt dialogue all exhibit feminist ideals that broke through societal barriers at the time of release in 1998.[23]. Historians believe Murphy created one of the first Black-owned lines to cater to women of all skin tones. The point is that sexual revolution tends to get in the way of actual revolution. Each of the characters have two Bartletsthe side that follows their gut, and the side thats swayed by forces yet unknown. Ad Choices. [19] Erika Bachiochi is a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center . [14] Feminist scholars have often discussed whether or not the decision to perform traditional gendered actions, such as shaving your legs and wearing short skirts can be considered an act of empowerment. If you're willing to let your sexuality diminish your power. 's office. Release Dates Episode. Ainsley Hayes Charlie Young I was just talking to Genevieve Koski about this scene, and she made the point that the scene might have been more effective if CJ was part of the conversation as well. Sam Seaborn "I've always noticed how a red lip on a white woman tends to be perceived as classic, polished, and elegant. This redefining developed, in part, as a response to the ideological backlash against radical varieties of second-wave feminism. Lipsticks with white bases and mattes don't cater to the Black consumer, as Hernandez points out. P.S. Charlie Young English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. Toby says yes but tells Leo it was personal - Leo remarks the President appeared upset after it. Dr. Stanley Keyworth is sitting in the lobby of the West Wing when Josh comes to get him. Purportedly as a new hardline of foreign policy, Toby has written a speech to be given at the UN conflating Islam with fundamentalism/terrorism. : Release Calendar Top 250 Movies Most Popular Movies Browse Movies by Genre Top Box Office Showtimes & Tickets Movie News India Movie Spotlight. : In the past two decades alone it's become a power play for Latinas, with Latinx icons like the late performers Selena Quintanilla and Celia Cruz, and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez boldly wearing the color on live television. The rhetoric of choice and empowerment is used to validate such overt sexual practices,[13] because they no longer represent coerced acquiescence to societally established gender roles, such as "the good girl," "the decent woman," "the abnegated mother," or "the virtuous sister" et ali. (Its also worth noting, before I get to Night Five, that The Two Bartlets has an amazing opening scene. Despite the stereotypes surrounding feminism and the dominate social narratives surrounding feminism during their time, women like Zora Neale Hurston and Emma Goldman argued that by using philosophical ideas of aesthetics and ideas of femininity, it is possible to empower and analyze the ways that gender works in everyday life. A lipstick continues to be seen as a symbol of beautification and something that is exclusively retained to have connotations representing femininity. "Let Bartlet Be Bartlet" is a phrase that's been thrown around a lot. : She is so damn funny. Damn right. And you know what? : We saw it on the fall 2017 runways, from Topshop to Prada, Jason Wu to Preen: lips in every shade of vermilion, from just-sucked-lollipop to vampire assassin . Charlie Young So. Why is this the case? Sam Seaborn He would be able to. Redefining terms were also influenced from the negative stereotypes generated during the second wave of feminism, such as "ugly feminist" or the "anti-sex feminist". Styling contours by colour and by line thickness in QGIS, How to tell which packages are held back due to phased updates, Short story taking place on a toroidal planet or moon involving flying. Each woman is challenging societal expectations and depicts qualities that television shows strayed away from at the time. Oh, that scene was classic. Isn't the point that Sam wouldn't have been able to find another way to be chummy with a woman who wasn't sexually appealing? "Mented Cosmetics was started by two Black women who couldn't find their perfect shade on nude lipstick," she explains. There, golden tubes of Arden's red lipstick were handed out to suffragists as a symbol of female empowerment. The West Wing, 2/6/02. Celia Walton : Charlie's a man. Toby prepared a remark for the President to use that would make it perfectly clear the President is in favor. And when someone said something that offended me, I did say so. Hes making some headway with Amy, though its kind of hard to tell, since shes doing things like 1) being dodgy, and 2) rejecting marriage proposals by members of Congress. Its just that you know how CJ gets annoyed when that one reporter wont let something go, and follows her around pestering her until he or she gets the answer theyre looking for? This movement is represented in the film Legally Blonde as it follows a former sorority girl, Elle, who gets a Juris Doctor degree from Harvard Law School, overcoming the stereotypes against blondes and triumphs as a successful lawyer without giving up her feminine qualities. Celia Walton Strength, passion, determination are just a few of the adjectives used to represent the color red however, Black women have been seen as the exact opposite when wearing it.". Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Stilettos? I embrace the attention it attracts because I no longer seek to blend in. [5] From early literature to date, the appearance of femininity has always had a negative relationship with feminism. But that isn't the point. I call it stiletto feminism. Josh ends the episode in a better place; Bartlet, fuming, throws Toby out of his office. If your sister is getting ready for a night out, and I said: "Deanna, you're enough to make a good dog break his leash " Would you think I was a cad? So. Nineteen and early twentieth century debates criticized the practice of doing things to change or improve ones appearance. Donna is at a bar meeting with an old friend, Casey Reed, who is starting up a new online news service. The point is, there are very few scenes in The West Wing that are so on-the-nose. : Stanley repeatedly asks Josh if they should go somewhere to talk (he is under the impression he is there for Josh). Toby is that guy for the President. Ainsley Hayes Celia Walton Isn't the point that Sam wouldn't have been able to find another way to be chummy with a woman who wasn't sexually appealing? : It saw Bartlet at his lowest but also his highest, and that journey made the second season so magical. You're Celia? I suppose I am. So Toby, to put it in Sorkin terms, is that guy. Thanks for contributing an answer to English Language & Usage Stack Exchange! Miranda was a direct and fiery lawyer who often was distrustful of the men in her life. "Founder of The Lip Bar, Melissa Butler, has talked about how lipstick has always been a powerful tool for her but wanted a socially responsible formula in vibrant shades. I don't even know what that means. C.J. Where Bartlet can turn on the charm, Toby has no charm. | Feminism is changing, and Barrett's replacement of Ruth Bader Ginsburg will show how. : We saw a similar use of red lipstick in late 2019 when thousands of Chilean women marched through the streets wearing blindfolds and red lipstick to denounce sexual violence in their country. Embracing Femininity: My Liaison With Lipstick. Sam Seaborn : Stilettos? Celia Walton Charlie's a man. In the U.S. television series, The West Wing, the 57th episode, "Night Five", features a scene wherein the characters debate the merits of lipstick feminism. Toby is different. Other feminists object that the so-called empowerment of lipstick feminism is a philosophic contradiction wherein a woman chooses to sexually objectify herself, and so ceases to be her own woman, in control neither of her self nor of her person. : [TOMT][quote] West Wing conversation on feminism . Every right. Hair-Color Removers Can Reverse Botched Dye Jobs But Are They Safe? They'll like us when we WIN!Toby Ziegler, No. : She has brought some language that she and several other congressmen would like to see inserted. Season two had Bartlet dealing with that grief as he came to terms with his MS deception. Ainsley as a character, though, is pretty great. What is the purpose of this D-shaped ring at the base of the tongue on my hiking boots? The thing about Bartlet is that he can inspire those around him but only occasionally takes action on what he believes is right. Lipstick feminism is a third wave feminist movement that supports the idea of accepting and embracing femininity to help women's empowerment. In one sense, the successes of second-wave feminism made it possible to reclaim aspects of femininity that were seen as disempowering, like make-up or stilettos. I would love to hear women's thoughts on this. By Ankita Bose Feb 26, 2021 3 min read. This is when his true nature comes outwhen there are no promises to fall back on, except he tries to make them anyway, since he's running for reelection. Next. : Secondly, it felt an awful lot like Sorkin tacked that scene on just so he can appease some hate mail he was theoretically getting about his portrayal of women. : Third wave feminism was birthed out of the demands of the second wave of feminism. I'd say Screw around if you want. Fittingly, the wildly divergent thing he did was announcing his candidacy for reelection, but thats beside the point. Charlie Young On Celia's side? I like sex. Toby and the President bicker over talking about affirmative action, and Bartlet heads to therapy. Carrie, the lead, was presented as an everywoman figure with her anxieties, insecurities, and emotional needs on the forefront. Like I said before, this season has been about reacquainting myself to the characters Ive lived with over the last two summers, and I realize more and more that the show needs Toby. Later, Donna brings a cup of coffee to Billy Price's wife. Toby has crossed a line, but then again, hes a writer, and writers say what they think regardless of consequence. But it's your money, it's about to be my money and I sleep fineSay what you'd say to any other patient, Women's BasketballListen, I can tell you're down in the dumps, but let's talk about me, I don't remember having to explain to Italians that our problem wasn't with them, but with Mussolini! Sam Seaborn "The Two Bartlets" is the most overtly related to the idea of a split personality. Get inspired by Liza Koshy's go-to quick and easy makeup look: 2023 Cond Nast. He's not a sexist. I like it when the guys tease me. However, what I learned from scenes like the one. Ainsley Hayes : So women of color were largely missing from this powerful show of unity for the betterment of American women. Ainsley Hayes Others, including Teresa Riordan, author of 'Inventing Beauty', insist it is much older, going right back to Victorian corsets and bustles and Marilyn Monroe's breast implants. and Wallace. Because of the sentiment or the expression? : The idea that feminism is decadent, and is destroying Western civilization; the idea that women's natural role is to have children, and to be subservient to men; the idea that strong men are. Sam Seaborn I would love to hear women's thoughts on this. For years, women Black women have seen themselves erased or totally unrepresented by foundation shades, primers, and even sunscreens. [2][3] In one sense, the successes of second-wave feminism made it possible to reclaim aspects of femininity that were seen as disempowering, like make-up or stilettos. | : There isnt much to say about Sam in this episode. [7] Women wanted to continue to fight for equality and to continue their activist work, while not fitting into the box of what society felt a feminist should look like. Ainsley talks about 'her kind of feminism'(which I agree most,btw) and Ginger describes it 'lipstick feminism'. "I want to set [them] on fire for what they represent," she says of the unused red lipsticks hidden away from the world. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! She agrees the only way she knows howdry wit-ily. Well, for the moment at least, I'm gonna do what she's telling me to do. : In The Two Bartlets, she fights with Toby over the merits of affirmative action, which at first seems surprising until she starts talking about her father. In S03E13, Celia point out Sam's comment against Ainsley's dress. For more information, please see our The Wing 'makes feminism a cool club that you can join as opposed to a social necessity,' one former employee says. This portable projector plays your movies in crisp, high-contrast, 1080p detailno matter where you are. I knew that my transition would not be received well as a Black trans woman living in the lower Midwest. Nonsense issues distract attention away from real ones. 1:47. Ainsley Hayes Obviously Ive talked about this a lot, since it comes up a lot, but theres not a single person on this show that doesnt look at Bartlet without even the slightest amount of reverence. "When I got older and began taking steps toward my transition, I bought my own red lipstick and reclaimed my power in its application. Women in Central and South America have claimed the color as a symbol of protest like the suffragists did over 100 years ago. The stigma around beauty practices started to diminish, and began being seen as a form of self expression as well as improving ones chances to be desired for a marriage.[5]. On how silly complaints move focus from the important stuff and such. Picture a group of women dressed in white gowns with suffragist sashes tied across their chests and wide-brimmed hats atop their heads adorned with flowers and feathers alike. Pop culture obsessives writing for the pop culture obsessed. So. And what kind of feminism do you call that? Photograph: Madeline Tolle/The Wing The Wing is a private members' space for women that claims to be an 'accelerator' for feminist revolution in. Was it just trying to say various stances? Sam: Stilettos? The female protagonist decides it is empowering, while determining that sex-negativism distracts from important issues like pay equity. In the Communications Bullpen - Sam greets Ainsley who was paged to return to the White House - he needs her to review a piece of legislation they plan to drop into the UN Speech. : is giving her last briefing of the day, when a newspaper editor, Leonard Wallace, comes to her to tell her that he is missing a reporter, Billy Price, who has vanished from the capital of the Congo. Then they get to psychological, and the President becomes dodgy about what happened four nights agowhich of course is when Toby suggested the President was fearful of putting himself out there, where he might lose followers and therefore disappoint his father for not being more of a success. Why does the US have to take every Arab country out for an ice cream cone?! . Ainsley Hayes "Instead I'd be in that other group that didn't belong or deserve to stand out. And that I'm all man. The attache turns back to Leo, telling him he can't talk to that woman. The second wave of feminism emerged in the US around 1960. I began analyzing how best to navigate the world in a safe, affirming manner.". When I started watching The West Wing, I naively assumed every character was Toby. Celia Walton : Isn't the point that Sam wouldn't have been able to find another way to be chummy with a woman who wasn't sexually appealing? Technical Specs. If one of main characters have narrow mind or different stance with TWW trying to tell, one of supporting characters (or other main character) point it out, others act like "Oh, she beats you." Technical Specs. This time around, he re-meets with the UFO guy from earlier in the shows run, who believes the government is stashing an alien ship in Ft. Knox where all the bouillon is. Toby is a man who picks his battles. Amy, who informs Josh of the rejected marriage proposal, visits him at 5 a.m. Josh, faux-cocky as ever, instead focuses on some tiny semanticsthat they went on six dates, not fourand tells her that he will explain everything when she calls him from her cellphone in 30 seconds. C.J. I said, I'm surprised you're willing to let your sexuality diminish your power. I suppose I am. Hes a little nuts. So he winks at the UFO guy, setting him down an even deeper rabbit hole of mystery and exploration. From that moment onward, red lipstick became an unofficial symbol of the suffragist movement at least for white women. We elected this guy two years ago, and though you think you know a guy, it's a whole new ballgame in his third year in office. Celia, I asked Ainsley, and she said she didn't mind at all. BARTLET FINDS LITTLE REST WHILE C.J. [5] These items included bras, girdles, curlers, false eye lashes, and magazines catered to women. CJ is the one whos outwardly opinionated, but isnt paid much heed by everyone else. I don't think whatever sexuality I may have diminishes my power. During the eighteenth century, writings of Wollstonecraft criticized women who focused on their beauty, calling them "feather birds" with nothing to do besides plume themselves. From the suffragists a hundred years ago to now, red lipstick will remain a powerful tool of protest but this time, BIPOC will not be erased. But all women don't have to think alike. You're Celia? BARTLET FINDS LITTLE REST WHILE C.J. Throughout most of Western history, women were confined to the domestic sphere . In 2018, men and women alike posted photos of themselves wearing red lipstick with the hashtag #SoyPicoRojo on social media to protest president Daniel Ortegas authoritarian actions in Nicaragua. | : It took off immediately, she started her own lipstick, and then makeup, line.". De Beauvoir urged that this was the way to equality for women. But they are no longer waiting for mainstream companies to cater to their beauty needs. | The point is that sexual revolution tends to get in the way of actual revolution. Company Credits Stanley asks Josh why that question? Toby is in Leo's office, where Leo is reviewing the draft of the speech the President will deliver to the United Nations on Monday. Can someone direct me to an episode or perhaps recap the conversation? Okay. Celia Walton Stilettos? Lipstick Feminism which is a cultural feminist movement with an attempt to respond and to b acklash second wave Radical feminism of 1960's - 70 by reclaiming symbols of `feminine' identity . Growing up, she associated red lipstick with being powerful, confident, and bold, but recognized a blatant double standard between herself, a Filipina, and the white women who wore the same bright lips. While it may take patriarchal discussions to the extreme at times, it is a key piece of media in furthering sexual liberation and sex positivity, a vibrant representation of what lipstick feminism is about.